The distinction between a backup completing successfully and a restore actually being usable is important. The `auth.uid()` issue is a good example of how a restore can appear successful while silently leaving gaps in the recovered database. One additional check I'd find useful is **application-level consistency after restoration**. Verifying that tables exist and files match their checksums is a strong baseline, but it doesn't necessarily prove that foreign-key relationships, Storage object references, and the application's expected access rules still work together. The custom smoke-test command seems like a good way to bridge that gap without trying to make the CLI understand every application's business logic. It would also be useful to see a final summary separating hard failures, skipped Supabase-managed dependencies, and checks that passed, so someone can judge recovery readiness without digging through a long restore log. A restore drill that clearly states what it verified—and what remains unverified—is much more valuable than a simple success message.
The part that stands out to me is the distinction between a test failing and a test being inconclusive. In permission testing, those are very different outcomes, and treating missing fixtures or request errors as proof that access is blocked can create a false sense of security. One challenge I can see with real applications is that the ownership rule isn't always as simple as `user_id = auth.uid()`. Access might depend on organization membership, tenant relationships, shared resources, or a join through another table. A test can pass for a basic owner-based policy while missing an unintended access path elsewhere. I'd be interested in how you'd extend this approach to multi-tenant data, especially when a user belongs to two organizations but should only access records belonging to the currently authorized tenant. That seems like a useful next test case because it checks the actual authorization boundary rather than just whether two users can read each other's rows. Keeping the scope narrow and reporting exactly what was tested is a good approach. The explicit positive controls make the results much more meaningful.